
Cultural Orientation Model
A new way to measure and understand identity.
The Problem
Marketers are stuck in the past.
01.
Over reliance on demographic variables to determine consumer behavior.
Too often marketers use demographic variables such as ethnicity and age as central organizing factors which flattens nuance and limits a deeper understanding of consumers beyond simplistic groupings.
02.
Equating Mainstream with "White" and assuming all other groups exist outside of it.
Marketers continue to believe that the "mainstream" is absent of culture and assign marketing budgets accordingly. Today, "general market" continues to be thought of as majority white and ethnic groups are positioned as "other".
03.
Relying on binary assimilation models centered around ethnicity.
Past acculturation models moved the needle in how we understand assimilation and cultural adaptation, however, there is an opportunity to capture more.

The Solution
The Cultural Orientation Model
A tool that measures consumers relationship to the mainstream to inform the types of marketing outputs they’d be most responsive to.
How It Works
Understanding Reference Systems
1
A reference system is the body of norms, people and practices a person implicitly checks against when deciding what is appropriate, valuable or true for themselves.
Everyone has a reference system, or many and they work to determine which products and brands people choose and whose opinions they weigh when doing making a decision.
2
The COM framework takes this reference system into account and places consumers across a spectrum based on how close or how far away they are from the mainstream.
The closer one is to the mainstream, the more likely they are to rely on external reference systems to inform their identities, perspectives and behaviors. The closer an individual is to their cultural core, the more likely they are to rely on an internal reference system to do the same.
The Cultural Orientation Spectrum
The spectrum consists of 4 different Orientation Fields and 12 zones spanning
from mainstream orientation to cultural core orientation.
Consumers in this space primarily organize their identities and daily decisions around mainstream cultural norms. Individuals who are more culturally open might land at the upper edge of this orientation field.
Mainstream
(MM)
Consumers in this space mostly shape their identities and decisions around a mainstream reference system but, they can also lean towards biculturalism in different contexts and within specific categories like food or fashion.
Mainstream Adjacent
(MM-A)
Consumers in this space are mostly led by their cultural cores however, they’ve learned to exist in and navigate through mainstream environments at varying levels of ease or, depending on who they are, with relative friction.
Cultural Core Adjacent
(CC-A)
Consumers in this space rely on their cultural centers as a primary reference system to inform their identities and guide their decisions. Those at the lower edge are slightly more open to mainstream influences than those in the center.
Cultural Core
(CC)
What This Helps Us Determine
Understanding which orientation fields consumers sit in can help marketers begin the process of stepping away from relying solely on demographic based marketing strategies that may tell only half the story.
Infact, in our study, we found that race, age and gender together account for about 7% of someone’s cultural orientation. Similarity, a 2026 GWI report found that out of 15 drivers of personal identity, age ranked 13th behind the top driver- values and beliefs which our model focuses on capturing more proactively.
What the COM framework illuminates is the fact that consumers with the same demographic makeup, existing in the same life stage can have completely different cultural orientations based on how, and where they were raised and the cultural values, behaviors and traditions that they choose to ignore, avoid or incoporate in their daily lives.
More than anything, it's important to recognize that the framework applies to all consumers- regardless of race. Marketers might assume that all white consumers would land in the mainstream side of the spectrum or all ethnic consumers would land on the cultural core side of the spectrum, but our study revealed that this was often not the case.
IDENTIFIES AS WHITE, 32, A MOM OF 3.
Cultural Orientation:
Mainstream Adjacent
Her sense of self is shaped more by the world around her than by a specific heritage. Her cultural background was present growing up but was never something her family worked to pass on, and it is not something she thinks about day to day. She does not feel she adjusts much between settings, because the mainstream is already her default.
Campaigns set in mainstream contexts are most ideal. Cultural specificity is not a barrier, but it is not a point of recognition either. She reads it as someone else’s story, told well.

Two people. Same Demographics. Different Cultural Orientations.
For Illustrative Purposes only
IDENTIFIES AS WHITE, 32, A MOM OF 3.
Cultural Orientation:
Cultural Core Adjacent
She was raised in a home where her family’s background was passed down on purpose, through food, holidays, language and expectations about family. It still shapes how she runs her own household, and she is aware of shifting between that world and the one she works in.
Mainstream-only campaigns are understood but not personal. She recognizes herself in work that shows a household holding two sets of traditions at once, and the specific detail is what earns that recognition.
Understanding these nuanced differences is the key to unlocking marketing strategies that actually resonate with consumers versus strategies built on antiquated assumptions based on consumers' age, ethnicity or gender.
IDENTIFIES AS BLACK, 38, A DAD OF 2.
Cultural Orientation:
Mainstream Adjacent
He grew up in a home with few traditions to carry forward. His family rarely marked cultural occasions, and his background is not something he thinks about during an ordinary week unless forced to do so. He does not feel he changes much between work and home.
Mainstream contexts and storylines that reflect his lifestyle and life stage (fatherhood) work well. Culturally specific campaigns won’t repel him, but they also won’t resonate as deeply as some may expect.

Two people. Same Demographics. Different Cultural Orientations.
For Illustrative Purposes only
IDENTIFIES AS BLACK, 38, A DAD OF 2.
Cultural Orientation:
Cultural Core Adjacent
He was raised with his family’s history made explicit, through sacred traditions passed down from generation to generation. This also shows up in how he is raising his own children. He is highly aware of the need for code switching and it comes at a cost.
Campaigns demonstrating a full understanding of his cultural background that make him feel like the people behind the campaign truly see him will make the biggest impact.
How COM Tool Was Built
The journey to building this solution has been
long in the making.
2012
Explored culture, power, race and hegemony at NYU and received a masters in Media, Culture & Communications in 2014.
2016
Became the youngest person to lead the Multicultural Practice for North America at Kantar Added Value.
2017
Co-led the Cultural Insights practice at Kelton Global which helped to shape today's perspective and approach on honing the power of culture and the macro forces that shape consumers' daily existences.
2020
Founded Insights in Color, a diversity initiative for the market research industry.
2019
Started Touch of Whit Creative, a multidiscipline strategy consultancy offering brand strategy, semiotics, cultural strategy and multicultural strategy to some of the world's leading global brands.
2021
Conducted the first of several identity projects for top, global brands where the cultural lenses of consumers were defined, explored and applied to the way their decisions and purchase behaviors are determined.
2021
Published the first Inclusive Research Standards Guide Book for the market research industry to identify best practices when recruiting and categorizing respondents in ways that ensure they feel fully seen, heard and understood.
2025
Wave I- Conducted a hypothesis study based on the ideas presented in the 2024 article to begin building a tool that considers how culture, heritage and background shapes consumer behavior and decision making.
2024
Authored "Marketing’s Failure to Adjust to the Decline of Monocultural Identity" to highlight the marketing industry's inability to see beyond the limitations of monocultural identity.
2026
Wave II- Validated the Wave I findings and initiated a second phase to build the instrument and validate the hypothesized scoring logic.
Published the results of the COM framework for retail consumption to begin gathering client partnerships for Wave III in 2027.

Wave I
A Hypothesis Study
341 completes.
29.3% Hispanic, 29.3% Black, 17.3% White, 16.1% Asian and 9.4% multiracial. Aged 16 and up.
50.1% men, 49.0% women and 0.9% non-binary or gender fluid. 76.0% were born in the United States, 22.0% were born outside it and 2.1% were born on American territory outside the United States.
Built to understand identity formation, spheres of Influence and their stated impact on consumer decision making & brand considerations.
What We Learned
The strongest relationship in the study was between how American someone rated themselves and how American they rated the people who raised them.
It held for mothers, fathers and for non-parent caregivers- no matter where the caregiver was born.
It was clear that tapping into identity formation at the point of childhood would be key to examine and factor into our model.
Cultural orientation is inherited from caregivers more than it is chosen.
Roughly three quarters of respondents said their cultural heritage was important to them, which eliminated the assumption that only ethnic consumers care to see their culture reflected back to them.
For our tool, this meant that ensuring a non-biased way forward that removed assumptions based on ethnicity would be key.
Heritage matters to almost everyone, not just people of color.
When asked their preferences most consumers agreed that they did not mind friendships with individuals outside of their race. However, when prompted again, far fewer claimed close friendships with people of different ethnic backgrounds.
Consumers' beliefs about culture vs. how they practice cultural openness proved to be two different things. For our tool, it meant we needed to be sure to ask about more than just what they believed in.
Stated values and lived behavior come apart don't always align.
When asked how much they share the attitudes and opinions of others, respondents credited caregivers, friendship groups and people of the same ethnic background. When asked about media's influence, it came back much lower.
We know media plays a larger role in shaping how people see the world than they give it credit for. This pushed us to move away from self-assessment style inquiry for wave 2 & toward things people can actually report, including the home environments they grew up in and the choices they have made since.
Media has the weakest stated amount of influence.
There was a 3pt gap in how respondents show up in society versus how they show up within their own communities.
Across both waves, the youngest respondents were the most likely to say they modify themselves to fit in with society. More than anything, multiracial respondents indicated having the highest gap between the two at 4pts and then 7pts respectively.
From this, we understood the need to include a measure for assimilation and code-switching in the second wave.
Almost everyone modifies themselves to fit in.
Identifying the gap between one’s stated identity (the performance) & their true identity is necessary to fully understand consumers as they truly are.
The larger the identity gap, the harder it is for brands to see past the “performed self” to connect with consumers’ authentic selves.
Understanding the identity gap not only helps brands develop the right messaging cues, but it also directs marketers to the appropriate the contexts and media channels the message(s) should be delivered through.
The "cost of performance" is causing marketers to miss the mark.
Rooting Ourselves
In Theory
Wave I revealed several gaps in the way consumers see themselves and believe themselves to be and how they actually act and behave in society. When we take the time to understand the layers of identity and the way scholars have defined the "self" we can build a better solution to capture the full weight of how identity informs and shape consumer behavior.
"The cultural self is shaped by the symbolic and normative systems in which we live: family traditions, moral codes, national identities, religious narratives and political commitments. This is the part of us that asks, What kind of person should I be? or What does my community expect of me?"
- David Intrator
W.E.B. DU BOIS (1903)
DOUBLE CONSCIOUSNESS & THE COST OF CULTURAL PERFORMANCE
"The pressure to code-switch, to downplay aspects of one's identity, is a direct manifestation of double consciousness, where one must constantly adjust their authentic self to conform to dominant cultural norms.“
Double consciousness theory describes the experience of measuring oneself through the eyes of a mainstream world that does not fully recognize one's authentic cultural self. The finding that 56% of respondents felt the need to modify themselves growing up, and 43% still do today may not be revelatory information but it is a key element to factor in. Most importantly, while initially designed around the Black experience, this framework pushes beyond ethnic restrictions.
ERVING GOFFMAN (1959)
THE PERFORMED SELF VS. THE AUTHENTIC SELF
"What others see is rarely a person's true self but rather a contrived set of behaviors and props used to complete the performance.“
Goffman's theory is the foundational academic source for the performed self / authentic self distinction. His frontstage (public performance) and backstage (authentic expression) theory explains findings in our study which indicated that consumers show up as themselves only 74% of the time in society versus 78% in community. This 4-point gap is the documented cost of frontstage performance identified sixty five years ago.
TORY HIGGINS (1987)
THE ASPIRATIONAL SELF AND SELF-DISCREPANCY
"The actual self represents the attributes someone believes they actually possess. The ideal self represents hopes and wishes. The ought self is determined through obligation & sense of duty. Self-discrepancy is the gap between these…”
Higgins’ actual/ ideal/ ought-self framework explains why the gap between “stated” cultural identity and “lived” behavioral practice produces an emotional tension. His theory explains why the gap between “high cultural heritage importance” and “low daily behavioral practice”, is an active source of emotional tension that motivates behavior. Consumers in this gap are not indifferent to their cultural identity. In fact, they are aspirationally connected to it but behaviorally constrained from expressing it.

"For market research, the implication is clear: If the self is inherently multiple, then consumer behavior cannot be reduced to a single identity framework. People do not bring the same self to the voting booth, the dinner table and the online checkout page." - David Intrator
We Also Learned That...
When it comes to factoring in identity, consumers expect different things from different categories.
When asked which categories they expect brands to take their identity into account in, clothing, (75.1%) food (71.3%), hair products ( 65.4%), shoes (58.1%), makeup and skincare (56.0%), and beverages ( 50.7%) landed at the top of the funnel.
Of the 15 categories presented, the average respondent selected 6.8 and the median was 6. Only 5.0% said there is no category where they expect identity to be considered.
"The consumer self emerges when individuals enter the economic sphere. It is a distinct identity mode activated by the unique conditions of consumption: choice abundance; aspirational messaging; low accountability; identity experimentation without social sanction; and hyper-personalized targeting." - David Intrator
If consumers buy identity, then marketing is not about persuasion. It is about recognition. The most effective brands do not convince people to become someone else. They reflect back a version of the consumer they already recognize, or aspire toward. -- Jodie Shaw
Leveraging What We Know to Build the Right Solution
The COM solution represents the next stage of understanding how consumers navigate between cultural systems. Past frameworks attempted to capture similar dynamics but narrowly focused on race, heritage and immigration status.
Original
Assimilation / Unidimensional Model
Assumed that cultural adaptation was a one-way street. The more a person adopted mainstream norms, the more they left their heritage behind. Heritage and host culture were treated as opposites, and assimilation was the assumed endpoint.
Evolution
Bidimensional Acculturation Model
Recognizes that heritage culture maintenance and mainstream culture adoption are two independent dimensions. Considers the fact that someone can be fully anchored in their cultural core while also navigating mainstream society with fluency.
Extension
Where We Are Today
A tool designed for all consumers regardless of background. It removes assumptions of previous models and measures not just where someone sits on the orientation spectrum, but also how they got there and whether that orientation is in transition.
Wave II
Building & Validation
593 completes.
The sample was comprised of iPhone and Android Users. 33.7% multiracial, 16.9% Black, 16.9% Asian, 16.9% White and 15.7% Hispanic. 50.3% men, 49.4% women and 0.3% non-binary or gender fluid. Aged 18 and up. 93.9% were born in the United States and 6.1% were born abroad.
Built around 5 Dimensions to Measure One's Relationship to the Mainstream:
Cultural Formation & Transmission, Relationship with Identity, Assimilation, Code-switching and Cultural Production & Participation
What We Learned
Demographics don't explain where anyone lands.
Ethnicity alone only accounts for roughly 6% of the variation in scores, age for about 1% and gender for well under 1%, and all three together for about 7%.
In fact in, the Cultural Core Adjacent Field held the majority of respondents, no matter their race, age or gender.
Almost nobody is fully Mainstream or Cultural Core Oriented.
The Cultural Orientation fields with the least amount of respondents existed at either end of the spectrum. The CC Orientation Field accounted for 11% of the sample and the Mainstream field accounted for the least at 2.7%.
This is likely reflective of the fact that what constitutes the "mainstream" has shifted.
The significance of one's cultural heritage is nearly universal.
Almost nine in ten respondents noted that their heritage was important to them, including a strong majority of White respondents.
The gap between stated and lived experience showed up here too as roughly half of the sample stated that it was important while simultaneously stating that they do not think about it day to day.
Cultural Orientation Drives Category Expectations.
The further toward the cultural core someone sits, the more categories they expect to reflect aspects of their identity.
Respondents at the mainstream end (27.5%) named 1.74 categories (out of 6) on average while respondents at the cultural core end of the spectrum (72.5%) named 2.91.
When asked whether there was any category at all where they expect their identity considered, 30.1% of the mainstream side said no, against just 9.5% of the cultural core side.
Relationship with Assimilation Shapes Brand Expectations.
The longer someone spends adjusting themselves to fit in, the more they expect from the brands they buy from.
Those who stated that they modified themselves to fit in growing up, and are still doing it today (32.5%), expect their identities to be considered in 3.21 of the six categories.
Those who have never felt that pressure (37.9%), expect it in just 2.06 categories. Individuals who adjusted growing up but have stopped today (25.3%) sit at 2.59 categories.
iPhone Users Have Higher Brand Expectations.
iPhone users have a higher degree of sensitivity about how they are perceived by others and may be more attracted to brands that feel like an extension of who they actually are.
The data found that iPhone users felt more pressure to adapt and fit in compared to Android users (31.7%) and still do today.
They were were also more likely than Android users to expect their identity to be considered when they shop for clothing (62.3% versus 47.0%) and for makeup and skincare (35.4% versus 26.7%).
"Consumers do not wake up thinking about brands. They wake up thinking about themselves. Brands enter the picture only when they fit naturally into that story.
We don’t buy products because they work. We buy them because they work for who we believe we are. That belief is emotional, social, and deeply human. Ignore it, and even the best product struggles. Respect it, and even ordinary products become meaningful.
In the end, identity is not a layer on top of consumption. It is the structure underneath it."
- Jodie Shaw
Wave III
Commercial Application
Pilot Studies
What it Will Consist of
Wave I & II were self funded. Wave III is seeking client partnerships for a new round of pilot studies to further test and finalize the framework. Additionally, our goal will be to focus more overtly on how cultural orientation correlates with consumer behavior in order to build more concrete branding and marketing implications.
How It Will Work
We carefully considered the most meaningful way to add value to our client's internal insights initiative. Our solution is designed to build off of internal client segmentations and typologies that have already identified viable audience targets. Your segmentation, our Cultural Orientation overlay.
What You Get Out of It
In addition to revolutionizing the way we think about consumer categorization, our goal is help clients further understand their current and aspirational consumer in new, more culturally accurate ways. Brands who already know who their customers are can be empowered to use this tool to learn more about their cultural orientation and build branding solutions that resonate more deeply and actually move the needle.
Sign up to be one of the first three pilot studies below.

